Consequentialism, war, and national defense william h shaw, 2014. A discussion of ethical dilemmas and sustainability initiatives. What, if anything, grounds the right of national defense. It is one of the most influential, and controversial, of all ethical theories. Consequentialism and moral worth utilitas cambridge core. Jun 05, 2018 download pdf show page numbers consequential validity evidence provides information about the social consequences that result from using a test for a particular purpose. Exploring how attribution theory sheds new light on the firm. Douglas portmores recent book, commonsense consequentialism. We identify three approachesempirical, theoretical, and philosophicalthat relate to the what, the how, and the why of using a practice lens. Utilitarianism is a type of consequentialist theory.
An archetypal consequential theory is utilitarianism, which states that the greatest happiness for the greatest number is the measure of right and wrong bentham, 1948, p. The implications of the consequentialist utilitarian approach are considered through the examination of a landfillsitesearch case study in ontario, canada. Consequentialist theory a discussion of ethical dilemmas and sustainability initiatives. Consequentialism isbn 9780415772570 pdf epub julia. Consequentialism slides lecture 1 free download as powerpoint presentation. It is a very simple, and very appealing, theory about our moral obligations. Nonconsequentialism and universalizability by philip pettit if nonconsequentialists are to embrace the requirement of universalizability, then they will have to adopt a surprisingly relativistic stance. A rule consequentialist theory of morality free epub, mobi, pdf ebooks download, ebook torrents download. Download new departures in marxian theory book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf. Utilitarianism john stuart mill mcmaster faculty of.
This paper sets out a novel challenge to consequentialism as a theory in normative ethics. Click download or read online button to get consequentialism and its critics book now. Broad in his 1930 book, five types of ethical theory. Design causality in the service of consequential theory show all authors. Jack kevorkian, a 63yearold retired pathologist, was charged with firstdegree murder after he helped an oregon woman with alzheimers disease commit suicide in june 1990. Using the big five factors as heuristics for organizing the research literature, numerous consequential relations are identified. In this paper i look at attempts to develop forms of consequentialism which do not have a feature considered problematic in direct consequentialist theories that is, those consequentialist theories that apply the criterion of rightness directly in the evaluation of any set of options. Consequentialism final journal of ethics and social. Psychological egoism pe pe is not to be confused with ethical egoism ee. I argue that this objection fails since those who pose this challenge either seriously oversimplify consequentialism s theory of value, misunderstand its theory of practical reason. If realistic liberal governance necessarily requires the consideration of both deontological and consequentialist ideals, how can theorists.
Consequentialist, deontological and aretaic moral theories each fasten on one of the facets of action that we normally take to be relevant to assessing its moral worth. Succinctly stated, consequentialism is the idea that the rightness or wrongness of action depends upon the consequences or effects of action, and can be broken down into four subcategories. This paper explores the differences between attributional and consequential greenhouse gas accounting methods, focusing on attributional corporate greenhouse gas inventories, consequential life cycle assessment, and projectpolicy greenhouse gas accounting. Urban sustainability in theory and practice by james, paul. In this theory, its less moral to risk your own life than to get killed saving someone else.
Consequentialism is the view that the rightness or wrongness of actions depend solely on their consequences. Plc topics, such as io bus networks, fuzzy logic, the iec 1 program. Non consequentialism not concerned with consequences consequentialism divides also into two major views. This book is essential for anyone who needs to understand how organizations work, evolve, and learn. Here we discuss consequentialism as a method for analysis for production, distribution and use of mass communication based on the theory described by john stuart mill, a nineteenth century. Adding a commitment function provides a synthesis which remedies the. Normative ethics consequentialism topics in consequentialism consequentialism and teleology. It is one of the most influential, and controver, isbn 9780415772570. New departures in marxian theory pdf book manual free download. No consequential damages sample clauses law insider. Besides being commonsensical, portmore also wants his theory to. The standards for educational and psychological testing american educational research association, 1999 views validity as a unitary concept that. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice.
Consequentialist theory is one of the normative ethics theories that try to answer the ethical questions about right or wrong and how we arrive at this answer. This essay explicates and defends a consequentialist answer to that. Most prominent philosophers of utilitarianism were jeremy bentham 17481832 and john stuart mill 18061873. One of the tasks moral theory might usefully accomplish is to set out in greater detail how each of these facets of action contributed to moral decision making and judgement. Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of ones conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of that conduct.
Consequentialism says that right or wrong depend on the consequences of an act, and that the more good consequences are produced, the better the act. Consequentialism and teleology bibliography philpapers. Robert nash 2002 explains how three moral languages rules and principles, charer, and basic beliefs act can be brought to bear on ethical. Download product flyer is to download pdf in new tab. Also we talk about the books commonsense consequentialism. Morality, is an ambitious, painstaking effort to render the moral requirements of conse. I will argue that consequentialist ethics is most appropriate when decisions are taken. Our primary measure of interest, like other recent studies e.
Thus, from a consequentialist standpoint, a morally right act or omission from acting is one that will produce a good outcome, or consequence. As a partial test to see how much relevance can be claimed of the axiomatized concepts of consequentialism and non consequentialism, two simple applications of this abstract framework are worked out. Here oderberg addresses the doctrine of the sanctity of human life and the arguments of leading ethicists who reject it as speciesist the fault line here between consequentialists in the style of peter. Ee can only work if you advocate some other theory and dont tell anyone.
The challenge is rooted in the ontological claim that consequences of actions do not exist at the time required to be that in virtue of which actions are right or wrong, and so consequences cannot play the role attributed to them by consequentialists. Black swans have shaped the history of technology, science, business and. Personality dispositions are associated with happiness, physical and psychological health, spirituality, and identity at an. Ethical egoism, ethical altruism, utilitarianism, and deweys theory of valuation. Consequentialism, war, and national defense william h. Consequentialism is a theory in the field of ethics.
I present no arguments against the view that some non consequentialist element having ones heart in the right place, for example must be part of any correct theory. After explaining the relevance and importance of this project, i clarify the meaning of consequentialism and explain how consequentialists understand and justify rights, including the right of national defense. Julia driver standard of right in consequentialist moral theory, by holding that the. Cities are home to the most consequential current attempts at human adaptation and they provide one possible focus for the flourishing of life on this planet. Deontological ethics is commonly contrasted to consequentialism, virtue ethics, and pragmatic ethics. Virtue ethics as an alternative to deontological and consequential reasoning in the harm reduction debate.
In no event shall the company be liable for any punitive, exemplary or other special damages, or for any indirect, incidental or consequential damages including lost profits or lost business opportunity, in each case arising under or in relation to this agreement including with respect to the performance or nonperformance of any services, whether. Consequentialism claims that the morality of an action is judged entirely by its consequences. A final section traces a recent history of the use of non consequentialist utilitarianism, explaining how the present notion of non consequentialist utilitarianism differs from will kymlickas and daniel jacobsons notions. Thus, in an agentneutral theory, an actors personal goals do not count any more than anyone elses goals in evaluating what action the actor should take. Gabriel abend northwestern university theory is one of the most important words in the lexicon of contemporary sociology. Utilitarianism an action is the right thing to do in certain circumstances if, of all the actions available in those circumstances, it would produce the best.
Consequential validity evidence sage research methods. Understanding the issues part one in a twopart series on euthanasia by j. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. Yet, their ubiquity notwithstanding, it is quite unclear what sociologists mean by the words theory, theoretical, and theorize. This paper explores what a responsible test developer would do to support the consequential validity of a test early in the development process, and how the. I want to demonstrate the structure of the most plausible and coherent version of virtue consequentialism. This essay attempts to show that sophisticated consequentialism is able to accom modate the concerns.
A final section traces a recent history of the use of nonconsequentialist utilitarianism, explaining how the present notion of nonconsequentialist utilitarianism differs from will kymlickas and daniel jacobsons notions. Article information, pdf download for consequentialism, war, and. Harvard university see all articles by this author. Consequentialist teleological theories of morality. I develop the argument that our current decisionmaking framework, utility theory, when used by itself, is 1 descriptively incomplete, 2 theoretically flawed, and 3 ethically questionable.
According to the axiological element, agents options can always be ranked in terms of how much aggregate value. The term deontological was first used to describe the current, specialised definition by c. The importance of ethics in the teaching profession. Teleology, utilitarianism, and christian ethics 603 states of affairs in which they result. The problematic feature in question which i refer to as evaluative conflict is the possibility that. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. View or download all content the institution has subscribed to. What are key features of consequentialist theories. Test bank for ethics theory and practice 11th edition by. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Download full test bank for ethics theory and practice 11th edition by thiroux krasemann pdf free 97803804058 03804054. Agentneutral consequentialism ignores the specific value a state of affairs has for any particular agent. Limitations to such an approach, in terms of differing values. Coupling attributional and consequential life cycle.
While some emphasized that sociological theory or social theory is a i w hati st he or y. In response, i offer an exploratory framework that incorporates both consequentialist and non consequentialist motivations. The moral value of an action can be judged by looking at the consequences it has. Actconsequentialism is generally characterized as a certain sort. However, for this to be realized in more than an ad hoc way, a substantial rethinking of current approaches and practices needs to occur. This essay explicates and defends a consequentialist answer to that question. In this terminology, action is more important than the consequences. Consequential theory an ethical theory that emphasizes the. Consequentialism simple english wikipedia, the free. It holds that an act is only moral or ethical if it results in a good conclusion. Read online new departures in marxian theory book pdf free download link book now. Brings together the thinking of one of the worlds leading management thinkers. This dissertation identifies and assesses three criteria that are often used to evaluate consequentialist theories of morality and rationality. Jan 01, 2011 consequential validity emerged from concerns related to societal ramifications of assessments.
This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Download as ppt, pdf, txt or read online from scribd. Consequentialism and moral worth volume 31 issue 2 nathaniel sharadin. Pdf consequentialist theory is one of the normative ethics theories that try to answer the ethical questions about. Consequentialism slides lecture 1 utilitarianism john. All action is for the sake of some end, and rules of action, it seems natural to suppose, must take their whole character and colour from the end to which they are subservient. Pdf consequentialist theory a discussion of ethical. The difference between consequentialist and non the. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click on download. Consequentialism is false, but only that a particular version of that view hedonistic consequentialism is false. Our decision to begin this lecture series on modern social theory with the question what is theory. Wherein morality meets rationality oxford moral theory, by douglas w. A consequentialist is what makes the decision one makes the right one, and there are key features to this, and they are.
Personality and the prediction of consequential outcomes. Non consequentialism and universalizability by philip pettit if nonconsequentialists are to embrace the requirement of universalizability, then they will. Introduction goes on to treat consequentialism as involving the production of optimal consequences and the possibility of consequentialist moral satisficing is never mentioned. Virtue ethics as an alternative to deontological and. Measures of personality have contemporaneous and predictive relations to a variety of important outcomes. All in all, pragmatic consequentialism as a moral theory faces serious difficulties in nondisaster settings. Consequentialism holds, in its most general form, that the moral quality of an action is completely determined by its consequences. Consequentialism and its critics download ebook pdf. After introducing a distinction between straightforwardly maximizing consequentialist theories such as act consequentialism and egoism and indirectly maximizing consequentialist theories such as rule consequentialism, rule egoism, gauthiers theory. One source of variance that has not been controlled for in these previous studies, however, is participants own moral judgments. In order to avoid dangerous climate change greenhouse gas accounting methods are needed to inform decisions on mitigation action. Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated supplements and figures.
The work is, even for nonbelievers, an important and engaging statement of non consequentialist moral theory kaspar lippertrasmussen, the philosophical quarterly, vol. As a political theory it is however entirely justified as a means of maximising the power of the state visavis other states. Comparative analysis of attributional corporate greenhouse. The difference between consequentialist and non consequentialist theories consequentialist theories they are normative ethical theory that provide criteria for moral evaluation and may also recommend rules or decision procedures for acting morally.
In this new edition, argyris discusses vital topics of current management research, such as tacit knowledge and management, so reflecting the evolving field of organizational learning. Introduction to philosophyconsequentialism wikibooks. Consequentialism and constraints consequentialist theories have two elements. One of the big theories that can be called consequential is called utilitarianism. In this book, julia driver introduces and critically assesses consequentialism in all its forms. This paper examines ethical concerns of the utilitarian paradigm, the greatest good for the greatest number, advocated by many proponents and consultants in siting landfills. Non consequentialism and universalizability by philip pettit if nonconsequentialists are to embrace the requirement of universalizability, then they will have to adopt a surprisingly relativistic stance. Urban sustainability in theory and practice responds to the crises of. Black swans are highly consequential but unlikely events that are easily explainable but only in retrospect. Utilitarianism is perhaps historically the most important form of consequentialism. Consequentialist moral theory springer for research. One might agree with nozick about the experience machine, and still be a consequentialist, if one holds that what makes one state of affairs better than another can sometimes depend on facts other than sensations of pleasure and. The final chapter of moral theory is really a bridge to the sister volume. It is also important to note that many use classical utilitarianism as the primary example of actconsequentialism, often using the two.
84 1101 1188 862 939 1075 330 1346 516 1427 713 6 1175 148 1051 1472 908 92 1432 618 544 227 1432 1163 611 899 1147 71 231 73 756 1 1246 183